Ari Millen

The Ice Cream Man / Jonathan Smiley

Charlie Zeltzer

Jared

Shiloh O’Reilly

Tommy

Kiori Mirza Waldman

Mia

Sarah Abbott

Lizzie

Benjamin Byron Davis

The Priest

Karen Cliche

Alison

Dylan Hawco

Chris

Luke Dietz

Elliot

Eli Massillon

Myles

Carina Battrick

Marcella

Ivano DiCaro

Hank

Sonam Kalsang

Sebastian

Charlie Storey

Piper

Rodrigo Fernandez-Stoll

Mr. Hamlin

Andriah Bryan

Mrs. Valentine

Darrin Baker

Principal Maloney

Amanda Barker

Heather Henderson

Kole Parks

Benji

Ryan Allen

Officer Salinger